All-Time Captains 2022 - 1869
| Year | Name |
|---|---|
| 1869 | William S. Gummere |
| 1870 | Alexander Van Rensselaer |
| 1871 | (records not available) |
| 1872 | David Marvel |
| 1873 | Cyrus Dershimer |
| 1874 | Isaac Lionberger |
| 1875 | Collins Denny |
| 1876 | A. J. McCosh |
| 1877 | W. E. Dodge B. Nicol |
| 1878 | Bland Ballard |
| 1879 | Bland Ballard |
| 1880 | Francis Loney |
| 1881 | Pendleton Bryant |
| 1882 | E.C. Peace |
| 1883 | Alex Moffat |
| 1884 | Clint on Bird |
| 1885 | Charles DeCamp |
| 1886 | Henry Savage |
| 1887 | Elwood Wagenhurst |
| 1888 | Hector Cowan |
| 1889 | Edgar Poe |
| 1890 | Edgar Poe |
| 1891 | R. H. Warren |
| 1892 | Phil King |
| 1893 | Tom Trenchard |
| 1894 | Tom Trenchard |
| 1895 | Langdon Lea |
| 1896 | Garrett Cochran |
| 1897 | Garrett Cochran |
| 1898 | A. R. T. Hillebrand |
| 1899 | Bill Edwards |
| 1900 | H. W. Pell |
| 1901 | H. W. Pell |
| 1902 | Ralph Davids |
| 1903 | John DeWitt |
| 1904 | W. L. Foulke |
| 1905 | Jim Cooney |
| 1906 | Herb Dillon |
| 1907 | Jim McCormick |
| 1908 | Ed Dillon |
| 1909 | Rudy Siegling |
| 1910 | Eddie Hart |
| 1911 | Eddie Hart |
| 1912 | Tal Pendleton |
| 1913 | Hobey Baker |
| 1914 | Wilder Penfield |
| 1915 | John Rush |
| 1916 | John Rush |
| 1917 | (wartime) |
| 1918 | (wartime) |
| 1919 | Hack McGraw |
| 1920 | Henry Callahan |
| 1921 | Stan Keck |
| 1922 | Mel Dickenson |
| 1923 | Whoops Snively |
| 1924 | Ed Stout |
| 1925 | Ed McMillan |
| 1926 | John Davis |
| 1927 | Charlie Moeser |
| 1928 | Chuck Howe |
| 1929 | John Whyte |
| 1930 | Ricardo Mestres |
| 1931 | Bill Yeckley |
| 1932 | Josh Billings |
| 1933 | Art Lane |
| 1934 | Mose Kalbaugh |
| 1935 | Pepper Constable |
| 1936 | Bill Montgomery |
| 1937 | Charlie Toll |
| 1938 | Tom Mountain |
| 1939 | Bob Tierney |
| 1940 | Howie Stanley |
| 1941 | Bob Peters |
| 1942 | Dick Schmon |
| 1943 | Wayne Harding |
| 1944 | (game captains) |
| 1945 | Neil Zundel |
| 1946 | Frank Perantoni |
| 1947 | Dick West |
| 1948 | Ed Mead |
| 1949 | George Sella |
| 1950 | George Chandler |
| 1951 | Dave Hickok |
| 1952 | Frank McPhee |
| 1953 | Homer Smith |
| 1954 | Jack Henn |
| 1955 | Royce Flippen |
| 1956 | Mike Bowman |
| 1957 | Jack Sapoch |
| 1958 | Fred T iley |
| 1959 | Frank Szvetecz |
| 1960 | Don Kornrumpf |
| 1961 | Ed Weihenmayer |
| 1962 | Dan Terpack |
| 1963 | Bill Guedel |
| 1964 | Cosmo Iacavazzi |
| 1965 | Paul Savidge |
| 1966 | Walt Kozumbo |
| 1967 | Lee Hitchner |
| 1968 | Dick Bracken |
| 1969 | Ellis Moore |
| 1970 | Dennis Burns |
| 1971 | Bob Wolfe |
| 1972 | Mike Kincaid |
| 1973 | Bill Cronin |
| 1974 | Tom Schalch |
| 1975 | Ed Sheridan |
| 1976 | Dan Fournier |
| 1977 | Bobby Isom Larry Lutz |
| 1978 | Greg Bauman Bob Ehrlich |
| 1979 | Matt McGrath Steve Reynolds |
| 1980 | Mark Bailey Paul Van Pelt |
| 1981 | Jono Helmerich Larry Van Pelt |
| 1982 | Vic Ruterbusch Jon Schultheis |
| 1983 | Steve Stearns Jeff Urbany |
| 1984 | Mark Berggen Chal Taylor |
| 1985 | Anthony DiTommaso Jim Petrucci |
| 1986 | Kevin Armstrong Ned Elton |
| 1987 | Matt Whalen |
| 1988 | Jason Garrett |
| 1989 | Franco Pagnanelli |
| 1990 | Mike Hirou |
| 1991 | Jim Freeman |
| 1992 | Aaron Harris |
| 1993 | Keith Elias Reggie Harris |
| 1994 | Mark Berkowitz Carl Teter |
| 1995 | Dave Patterson |
| 1996 | Jimmy Archie Marc Washington |
| 1997 | Mike Clifford Tim Greene |
| 1998 | Dan Swingos |
| 1999 | Hamin Abdullah David Ferrara Chuck Hastings |
| 2000 | Michael Higgins |
| 2001 | Robert Farrell |
| 2002 | Drew Babinecz Chisom Opara |
| 2003 | Tim Kirby Dave Splithoff |
| 2004 | Justin Stull Jon Veach |
| 2005 | Ben Brielmaier Justin Stull |
| 2006 | Luke Steckel Jeff Terrell |
| 2007 | Brendan Circle Jon Stem |
| 2008 | Brian Anderson Adam Berry Matt Koch |
| 2009 | Scott Britton Wilson Cates Jordan Culbreath Mark Paski |
| 2010 | Steven Cody Jordan Culbreath Matt Zimmerman |
| 2011 | Mike Catapano Steven Cody Tommy Wornham |
| 2012 | Mike Catapano Andrew Starks |
| 2013 | Phillip Bhaya Caraun Reid |
| 2014 | Quinn Epperly Mike Zeuli |
| 2015 | Matt Arends Seth DeValve |
| 2016 | Chad Kanoff Joe Rhattigan Dorian Williams |
| 2017 | Chad Kanoff Kurt Holuba John Lovett |
| 2018 | John Lovett Kurt Holuba Mark Fossati Tom Johnson |
| 2019 | Graham Adomitis John Orr Jake Strain |
| 2020 | No Season |
| 2021 | Collin Eaddy Trevor Forbes Cole Smith Jeremiah Tyler James Johnson Nikola Ivanisevic |
| 2022 | Carson Bobo Henry Byrd Dylan Classi Andrei Iosivas Matthew Jester Uche Ndukwe Michael Ruttlen Jr. |
| 2023 | Liam Johnson Ozzie Nicholas Jalen Travis Blake Stenstrom |